Picture a $2,400 debit card payment that a consumer reports as unauthorized. For the card issuer, the notice starts a clock under Regulation E: 10 business days to decide, or up to 90 days for a point of sale debit card payment if it credits the consumer provisionally. For the bank holding the merchant's account, the payment is one more alert, and its suspicious activity report clock has not started.
There, AML transaction monitoring raised the alert, and an analyst has to close it with a reason or open a case.
What is a fraud investigation, and what is an AML investigation?
A fraud investigation establishes whether a customer or the firm lost money through deception, and who carries the loss. An AML investigation establishes whether activity is suspicious enough to report to the financial intelligence unit (FIU). Both are financial crime investigations. For suspicious activity, the FFIEC examination manual lists where alerts can come from: "employee identification, law enforcement inquiries, other referrals, and transaction and surveillance monitoring system output".
The two meet on the same accounts. FinCEN's alert of 9 January 2026 notes that fraud "continues to be the largest source of illicit proceeds in the United States", citing Treasury's 2024 risk assessment. complead, formerly Sanction Scanner, runs fraud and AML on one platform: it assesses both risks from the same customer data and events, so the two teams read one record.
An AML analyst or a fraud analyst works the alert. The FFIEC wants the final SAR decision to rest with a decision maker, "whether an individual or committee", who holds that authority.
How is a fraud investigation different from an AML investigation?
One disputed card payment shows the split. The issuer handles the claim and answers the customer on a timetable a rule sets, such as Regulation E. The merchant's bank asks why its customer keeps receiving disputed money, and its reporting clock starts only with its own finding. The merchant may suspect chargeback fraud.
How does an alert become a case?
An alert becomes a case when triage cannot close it.
Table 1. What each stage puts on the record
| Stage | Input | Output on the record | Who decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Triage | alert, risk rating, earlier alerts | closed with a reason, or opened as a case | analyst |
| Investigation | transactions, counterparties, customer file, open sources | findings against the alert's pattern | investigator |
| Evidence | documents, logs, other teams' answers | evidence attached to the case | investigator |
| Write up | findings and evidence | case note: reasoning and recommendation | investigator |
| Decision | the case note | SAR or STR, closure with its reason, or exit | the authorized decision maker; in the UK, the nominated officer |
| After the decision | the decision and its date | records kept (US: five years from filing); continuing activity SARs (FinCEN's timeline optional) | the decision maker |
Triage sets the order of work. The EU's AML Regulation, which firms apply from 10 July 2027, puts that in law: where necessary, firms "shall prioritise their assessment" by the urgency of the transaction or activity and the risks in their Member State. A fraud score on a card alert or a monitoring rule's risk weight can set that order.
In the US, the FFIEC asks for "a clear and defined escalation process from the point of initial detection to disposition of the investigation". AML case management software records that path.
Which rules set the clocks on an AML or fraud investigation?
Most reporting clocks start when the firm finds suspicion, and most customer clocks when the customer complains.
Table 2. Clocks that bind an investigation (as of November 2026)
| Rule | What starts it | Length | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| US SAR, 31 CFR 1020.320 | initial detection of facts that may be a basis for a SAR | 30 calendar days; 30 extra if no suspect is identified; 60 at most | banks |
| US electronic fund transfer errors, 12 CFR 1005.11 | the consumer's notice of error | 10 business days; 45 days with provisional credit (90 for point of sale debit card, foreign initiated or new account transfers) | new account (first 30 days): 20 business days, not 10 |
| UK disclosure, POCA s330 | knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds for either, from regulated business, that may help identify the launderer or property | "as soon as is practicable" | disclosure to the nominated officer or an authorized NCA officer |
| UK DAML, POCA s335 and s336A | the disclosure | 7 working days; 31 days from any refusal | court extensions capped at 186 days in total |
| EU AMLR, Articles 69 and 71 | knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds to suspect; an FIU request | report promptly; answer FIU requests in 5 working days, unless the FIU shortens (even below 24 hours) or extends that; a held transaction may proceed, after a risk assessment, if no contrary FIU instruction comes within 3 working days of the report | from 10 July 2027 |
| EU PSD2, Article 73 | noting or notice of an unauthorized payment | refund immediately, by close of the next business day at the latest | unless it suspects fraud on reasonable grounds and tells the national authority in writing |
| UK APP reimbursement, PSR | an individual, microenterprise or charity's claim | 5 business days; an outcome within 35 business days if the firm stops the clock | Faster Payments and CHAPS |
FinCEN's continuing activity timeline (a further SAR on day 150 after a day 30 filing) applies only to firms that elect it: its October 2025 answers say firms "are not required to do so", nor to run a separate review after filing to see whether the activity continued.
When does the SAR clock start?
An inheritance lands in a salary account. The monitoring system flags it. The FFIEC manual uses that case, beside a gift and a real estate purchase or sale, to say a flag "should not be considered initial detection". The 30 day period starts only after "an appropriate review is conducted and a determination is made" that the transaction is suspicious. No fixed length applies to that review, but it "should be completed in a reasonable period of time".
What evidence does an investigation keep, and for how long?
Under US AML rules, a bank keeps the SAR and its supporting documentation for five years after the filing date, and that documentation is "deemed to have been filed with the SAR". From 10 July 2027, the AMLR adds a record of each assessment, filed or not, kept five years from the end of the relationship, the occasional transaction or a refusal.
- Customer file and risk rating. The alert is read against the activity the file expects.
- Transactions, counterparties and logs. Authentication logs beside the payments can show accounts that share a device.
- Open sources and adverse media. Press, court and registry records test what the customer said.
- Earlier reports and requests. Prior SARs, law enforcement inquiries and any match on a FinCEN 314(a) request can show whether this is a pattern.
- The analyst's reasoning. The AMLR record holds "the information and circumstances considered and the results".
- The decision and who made it. A name and a date show the escalation path the FFIEC asks for.
In the UK, section 342 of POCA makes falsifying, concealing, destroying or otherwise disposing of relevant documents, or causing or permitting that, an offense once a person knows or suspects that an officer, or in Scotland a proper person, is acting, or proposing to act, in a money laundering investigation, unless the person did not know or suspect their relevance or did not mean to hide their facts.
How is the case written up?
The case note joins the evidence to the decision and says why the activity is or is not suspicious. When the case ends in a SAR, a FinCEN alert can request some of its words. The Minnesota alert of 9 January 2026, on fraud rings exploiting federal child nutrition programs, asks filers to put the key term FIN-2026-MNFRAUD in SAR field 2 and in the SAR narrative, and to select field 34(z) for other fraud, with "Federal Child Nutrition Programs" in its text box.
On complead, the AI copilot summarizes a case, answers plain language questions about it and proposes a next step. It does not close the case. A person or a rule does, and the analyst's decision with its reason becomes the case note.
How does a case end: SAR, closure or exit?
A case ends in a report to the FIU, a closure with its reason, or a customer exit. On a decision not to file, the US and EU differ. On 9 October 2025, FinCEN and four federal regulators answered that the BSA and its rules carry "no requirement or expectation" to document it, and that "a short, concise statement" is likely enough in most cases for a firm choosing to. AMLR Article 77(1)(b), from 10 July 2027, requires a record of every assessment "whether or not" it leads to a report.
In the UK regulated sector, a person who, through the business, knows or suspects money laundering or has reasonable grounds to, and can identify the launderer or the property (or may help to), tells the nominated officer, often the MLRO, who decides on a report to the NCA.
The customer is not told. A US SAR, and anything that would reveal one, stays confidential. Under POCA section 333A, a person in the regulated sector who reveals that suspicion was reported, or that a money laundering investigation is being considered or carried out, commits an offense where that is likely to prejudice an investigation and the person knows or suspects it is, unless an exception in sections 333B to 333D applies. From July 2027, AMLR Article 73 bars telling the customer that activity is being or was assessed, that information is being, will be or was sent to the FIU, or that an analysis is, or may be, carried out.
What happens when a fraud refund meets a DAML?
Take the payment to the UK (illustrative). The merchant's bank holds £14,000 from a run of disputed card payments and asks the NCA for a "defence against money laundering" (DAML) before paying out. On day three of the notice period, a £2,400 chargeback arrives. The UKFIU's DAML guidance says such funds stay frozen, so the bank may be unable to pay "even to a victim through a chargeback claim" until a court order or a granted DAML, unless the UKFIU accepts an amended prohibited act.
The same guidance treats a refund to a victim of crime as needing no DAML, provided the firm does nothing within sections 327 or 328; a SAR made for that purpose carries the glossary code XXVICTXX. Below the threshold amount, £3,000 since 31 July 2025, a bank or an electronic money or payment institution operating an account commits no offense under sections 328 and 329, nor under section 327 when converting or transferring, so needs no DAML.
What changed in 2026?
- 13 January. A geographic targeting order required banks and money transmitters in two Minnesota counties to keep and report records of certain payments at or above $3,000, from 12 February.
- 10 April. FinCEN published a proposal to rewrite AML/CFT program rules, asking whether "escalation and reporting protocols" must be written; still a proposal.
- 2 July to 20 September. AMLA consulted on the format of suspicion reports; results are to follow.
- 16 October. The NCA's SARs annual report put DAML requests about 23 percent below 2024 to 2025, mainly after legislative changes such as the threshold rising from £1,000 to £3,000.
Three steps for this week:
- Write down the event that starts your SAR clock.
- Check that every closed alert keeps its reason; an EU firm needs that record from July 2027.
- Agree with the fraud team who answers a chargeback on an account under a DAML.